P
Proper Cloth Custom Oxford
$100–$150
8.4
Quality Score
Excellent
8.4
Value Score
Excellent
—
Community (0 votes)
Not rated
Sub-scores
fit
9.5
value
8.5
fabric
8.5
construction
8.5
Analysis based on aggregated reviews from expert sources, Reddit, and YouTube.
Pros
- +Made-to-measure at ready-to-wear prices ($80-300 per shirt)
- +Hundreds of fabric options from top mills (Thomas Mason, Albini, Canclini)
- +Perfect Fit Guarantee — free remakes if the fit is off
- +Consistently accurate fit across multiple orders
Cons
- −Requires creating a size profile — learning curve for first order
- −First shirt often needs adjustments before perfecting measurements
- −Online only with limited physical presence (NYC showroom)
Best for
Anyone tired of off-the-rack shirts that don't fit right.
Common complaints
Expect the first shirt to be a sizing exercise — it gets perfect from shirt two onward.
Summary
Proper Cloth is unanimously praised on r/malefashionadvice as the best value custom shirt. Made-to-measure with premium fabrics at ready-to-wear prices, with a Perfect Fit Guarantee. The first shirt is a learning experience, but once your profile is dialed, every shirt fits perfectly.
Community Reviews
No reviews yet. Be the first to rate this product!
Sign in to rate this product
Sign in